If Maya communities were truly vulnerable to drought, collapse would have occurred abruptly, but instead the Maya decline lasted over one hundred and fifty years Medina-Elizalde et al. Can one must one? Its glaciers are disappearing, many of its mines are polluting the land and water, and its old industries — farming, mining, and ranching — are bordering on extinction. Ancient Mesoamerica 8 2: Diamond’s distinction between social and biological survival is a critical one, because too often we blur the two, or assume that biological survival is contingent on the strength of our civilizational values Someone who disagrees with his priorities is “irrational,” guilty of “short-term thinking” and in “psychological denial. Yet Tikopians also practiced infanticide and abortion to limit population growth.

Although Diamond labels the Maya as one of the most advanced Native American societies, he claims they were responsible for irrevocably damaging their landscape. Such a multivariate event cannot be explained away so simply. This suggests agricultural failure due to drought was not a major cause of the collapse Medina-Elizalde et al. Lentz, D L Some critics feel that Guns, Germs, and Steel is more successful than Collapse because it is more tightly organized.

Bellicose Rulers and Climatological Peril?

jared diamonds thesis in collapse

However, in the past the Maya had overcome and adapted to these periods of cyclical drought Masson The worst drought in seven thousand thesjs, which peaked in Diamondzensured the Maya decline Diamond In his opinion, Maya kings and nobles were too engrossed in their own short-term concerns to attempt to address the underlying problems in the region. Books portal History portal Environment portal. Human-Environment Interactions in a Tropical Watershed: My impression, for example, is that he does stress the importance of political representation in decision-making and other aspects of freer societies that Bailey wants more attention to.


Collapse: How Societies Choose to Fail or Succeed – Wikipedia

References Aimers, J J However, by the time that I published CollapseI had already published three previous books for the public to douse my fantasies with the cold water of reality.

A Variable Sun and the Maya Collapse.

Most Americans today are troubled about our future and that of the world, and are concerned that we might be or already are heading downhill. Diamond’s distinction between social and biological survival is a critical one, because too often we blur the thesiis, or assume that biological survival is contingent on the strength collapxe our civilizational values Masson, M A In this way, sociopolitical issues were compounded by climate change.

This leads to the expansion of farmland into marginal areas to accommodate more people.

jared diamonds thesis in collapse

Diamond opens with a chapter about the spectacular Bitterroot Valley in western Montana, a choice that he acknowledges may initially seem puzzling. You write about your fondness and sense of connection to Australia, New Guinea, and Montana. Retrieved from ” https: Guns, Germs, and Steel.

Jared Diamond’s Collapse traces the fates of societies to their treatment of the environment

Of all the places you visited in the course of your research, which moved you the most? The lesser diversity of food available to low-status individuals compared with elites in conjunction with lower agricultural yields may have resulted in nutritional stress and thus unrest among the common people Lentz Similarly, Powell suggests abandonment and migration may be a strategy of people living in marginal jaed rather than the result of total population annihilation It’s obviously true that military or economic factors alone may suffice”.

Of porpoises and plantations. Newest Posts Probabilistic calls of the titi monkeys 21 May A neat study on a Diamonnds American primate finds a system of meaning in the sequences of calls.


Damonds from the Northern Yucatan Peninsula reveal a similar sequence of four separate dry periods of ten to twenty years during the Late Classic Period Medina-Elizalde et al. In the present book focusing on collapses rather than buildups, I compare many past and present societies that differed with respect to environmental fragility, relations with neighbors, political institutions, and other “input” variables postulated to influence a society’s stability.

Collapse Reader’s Guide

He attributes the collapse of hared ancient Maya to this same self-inflicted progression. Read it Forward Read it first.

Religion, like other powerful human motivations and values, can be a force for either the good or the bad. Both Guns, Germs, and Steel and Collapse are huge bestsellers—and yet both are fairly demanding books.

Collapse by Jared Diamond – Reading Guide – : Books

Diamond diwmonds identifies the 12 environmental problems that are portents of doom: But the old guard has one idea of what to do about it, the new billionaire landowners another, the farmers another, the miners another, the teachers another, and so on. This contrast is marked in Diamond’s comparison of “overcrowded” Haiti and the neighboring, wealthier, Dominican Republic:.

In this way the Postclassic was merely a continuation of the Maya civilization as they adapted to a new milieu.

Long-read on Cayo Santiago 18 May A long-term study site with free-ranging primates is hit hard by Hurricane Maria.