In this situation, you have an option of committing torture techniques on them. A foreign automobile company has recently entered the Indian market. We provide a solution. And as a captain, he knows best. My mistake, i didn’t read that. In this situation it would be absurd, he thought, to decide by drawing lots who should be thrown overboard. How do you resolve it?

That would include a re-evaluation as to whether things are in compliance. In current affairs reading Editorials Online needs an in-depth focus and hence we provide a separate analysis of daily editorials which is not found in any other website. Minimise the damage to all affected help everybody you can within the law. Please don’t provide “out of the box” solutions that evade the moral question. Even in the exam, I think we should consider the stated facts as true or else it defeats the purpose of the ethical case study.

Regarding the first set of questions: Say the case study were slightly different– You are Municipal Commissioner and it has come to your notice that an apartment’s permissions were acquired by bribing officials. I’d follow the government order in this case. Upsc Book for Ethics in Market??

Some food for thought: Anyhow no legal action can frumias taken, but you can be shifted to less important positions.

Also how to approach Ethics?? And in my opinion its not the crime that should be stopped but the criminal mentality. For ex- the govt has clearly ruled out your venturing into certain blocks of your districts you are the DC- again because there is a fear that you will the kidnapped again the Maoists.


UPSC Ethics Case Studies Initiative |

Are you guys reading on these lines? Now you think that these people must foruias about where the bombs have been planted. Is this a correct way of writing thr answer to such questions? Arindamsarkar Also humans are set apart by their way of thinking and helping each other too. Siddharth I googled this a bit and basically there is no right answer to this question.

Ethics Case Study – NREGA

I would communicate to the government the need to visit this areas, and request security cover. Fprumias you assume, like our Captain, that not throwing anyone overboard would necessarily mean that everyone dies. Otherwise you wouldn’t need judges or officers with discretionary powers. Their most important responsibilities are maintenance of Law and Order and internal security.

UPSC Ethics Case Studies Initiative

But when they get to know that you are going to be transferred they requested you to do something to prevent the transfer. But doing so would displace several low-income groups that have invested their life savings into this.

And the schools might not open again. If you had been on the jury, how forumiass you have decided? Just want to check if I need to change direction!!

Cse you think some times rules are to be followed on your discretion and if you help him in paying for medicines, he hasnt committed any crime. He should act in the best interest of his crew.

ForumIAS provides the right approach to excel in this exam through their toppers who have shared their success mantras and their study materials in an elaborate manner.


The most unique thing about it is that they are handwritten by toppers themselves. Since it is clear that he is acting out of self-preservation, it can be assumed that he may have thrown over more people than would have been necessary. I think you meant the first case – so the building has to brought down acc. The crew of future ships will have no faith in their captain, if it were to be pronounced that what the present captain did was unethical and amounts to murder.

The case of Paradise Papers |

I could not even attempt marks. But, as i am not a judge or a robinhood, if i feel that what he is saying is true and want to leave him, i will give him the money for buying those medicines either from my pocket or any social organisation abd make him pay to the pharmacy.

On the other side, is it fair for your friend to put his own interest ahead of the author’s right to compensation?

case study forumias

Plus, a pusillanimous officer will replace you so that the matter can be hushed up. The reputation of the deceased in the village was not good. Their most important responsibilities are maintenance of Law and Order and internal security.

case study forumias

However, instead of any action being taken you are informally advised that if you persist you will be transferred.